Will you see the blind trial opinion in the formal defense?

The formal defense will look at the blind trial opinions.

Formal defense meeting is a form of academic paper defense, which is usually held after the paper is submitted or after the preliminary examination. In the formal defense meeting, students need to show and explain their research results to the designated expert committee (hereinafter referred to as the "committee") and answer the questions and opinions raised by the committee one by one.

Blind evaluation opinion refers to that students' papers are reviewed by special blind reviewers in the process of submission and preliminary examination, so as to ensure the fairness and objectivity of academic research. Blind reviewers will evaluate the quality, innovation, methods, conclusions and other aspects of the paper, and put forward specific suggestions for revision and improvement, so that the paper can meet higher academic requirements.

In the formal defense meeting, it means that at the defense meeting, students need to consider and explain the opinions and suggestions put forward by blind reviewers, as well as the comments and questions put forward by the Committee on the thesis and defense. This means that students need to fully grasp their own research results and be able to explain and answer relevant questions clearly and accurately, thus proving that their research has the level and value of academic research.

On the importance of blind trial opinions in formal defense;

1 to improve the fairness of evaluation.

Because the judge does not know the identity and background of the specific researcher during the blind trial, the fairness of the evaluation process can be guaranteed to the greatest extent. The formal defense meeting needs to consider selecting one or more multi-person groups. In addition to participating in the blind trial, they are also invited to express their opinions mainly in the defense session, thus ensuring the fairness of the defense session.

2. Confirm the research quality.

Blind trial opinions usually provide opinions and opinions of respected scholars or researchers. The critical opinions and suggestions provided by these experts are the most concerned by researchers and the National Defense Commission, and have high credibility and authority. Therefore, the formal defense meeting will help to evaluate the quality of the research, find out the existing problems and the direction of improvement, so as to provide more scientific evaluation results.

3. Promote academic exchange meetings and technological innovation.

The combination of defense meeting and blind trial opinions can increase the opportunities of academic exchange and technological innovation, and further stimulate the motivation of exploration and further research in new fields. Therefore, the formal defense will have a positive impact on the quality and output of academic conferences and promote the development of academic exchanges and innovation.