Why is Shangsanchinobu suspected to be a woman?

It was first published in March of the 44th year of Showa (1969), and then published an album of the serial novel "Is it a man or a woman to believe in goodness" published in Yomiuri Shimbun. Later, it led to the creation of Japanese literary circles, such as Komatsu Satoshi, who created a novel in which modesty and faithfulness fell in love and fought Nobunobu and Konka together. The following information has been proved to be false:

False theory 1: According to historical records, Shangshan Qixin died of "gynecological diseases".

Contemporary records show that Kenshin died of a "blade". It is said that Japanese "blade" is the code word of "menstruation", so it is interpreted as menopausal syndrome.

Song Ping Zhong Ming, the author of Contemporary Records, was born in Tianzheng 1 1 (1583) some time after Shang Shanggan's death. Contemporary records are not first-hand information. Whether this information is accurate or not is controversial.

There is an attached certificate that "Fukui Prefecture official coin shrine has a' blade shrine' dedicated to the gods in charge of women's diseases." It has been verified that Dachong Shrine in Qian Yue City, Fukui Prefecture has nothing to do with gynecological diseases.

Now almost all Japanese historians believe that he died of hypertension caused by excessive drinking and salt, and some people think that he died of esophageal cancer and advanced gastric cancer.

Compared with the research of historians and the analysis of professionals, "gynecological diseases" is only a speculation and a false statement.

Pseudo-theory 2: the strange physiological cycle of Shang Xin

Rumor has it, "This is proved by a lot of historical materials. This guy got a very strange disease in Shangshan Qianxin, that is, he had abdominal pain every month or so 10, so he couldn't ride a horse.' Kenshin 10 had abdominal pain', which was recorded in the military records of Shangshan's family. The cause of abdominal pain ... is unknown. "

Many examples were cited, such as "When going to the Kanto War, Shangshan Army had already fought the northern route, and on June 1 1, Shangshan suddenly had abdominal pain and retreated to the covered bridge city. This is clearly recorded in Song Pingji. "

We didn't know until we checked the information that the rumor was deliberately screening favorable historical materials. Counterexamples are: the fourth Kawasaki Island War, Lu Yong attacked Yeqi City in seven years (1564), Lu Yong attacked Numata City in nine years (1566), Lu Yong 1 1 year, and 6550. They are all fighting in the "physiological cycle" as rumored, and there is no record of abdominal pain in Shangsanchinobu.

This shows that this statement is false.

Myth 3: Kenshin is an indomitable spirit, but unexpectedly, she gave up women completely.

The myth says: "Although it can be explained by religious complex, can that kind of saint-like emotion exist in a person who doesn't care about war at all?" Why give up color if you don't give up killing? And if Kenshin is a woman to explain, it would be much easier. And as we all know, there are often two kinds of strong women, one is particularly strong desire, and the other is almost no desire. Kenshin seems to belong to the latter. "

Here is the gossip that deliberately misleads the direction of thinking. Killing has nothing to do with women's sex, gossip is attached on purpose.

Pseudo-theory 4: Records from Foreign Countries

According to rumors: "At that time, the Portuguese knew a lot about Japan, while neighboring Spain dominated the maritime hegemony, so they spared no effort to explore the East. King Philip II, who established an invincible fleet to dominate the Seven Seas, once sent businessmen to the East to look for gold and spices, and also inspected the local situation.

One of them named ゴンザレス (I don't know how to spell it) sent a report back to Philip II, mentioning Huijin.

Uesugi Kagekatsu (At that time, Shangshan had been transferred to Huijin). The report mentioned:' His Tia used to develop land and dig gold mines, and later all the gold was transported to the present territory.' -Probably no one doesn't know Zuo Dujin developed by Shangshan.

Sugiyama Akashin is actually Jingsheng's uncle. This is a problem, because in Spanish, "uncle" is "TiO" and "TIA" is "aunt".

In other words, through what channels did foreigners know: Shangshan is a woman, and he is Jingsheng's aunt rather than uncle. "

"Tia" means not only "aunt" in Spain, but also "friend" on some occasions. According to the context, this should be the former, but the possibility of "typo" is not ruled out.

In addition, in Japan at that time, there was no saying that "Shangshan is a woman", and "Shangshan is a woman" was put forward in 1969.

Moreover, at that time, Shang Shan Kenshin's rivals Konka and Soo-kyi didn't make such favorable rumors and attack their opponents. It can be seen that the remarks here are only speculation and false.

Myth 5: Metaphor in the Portrait of Shangshan

Rumor has it: "Many famous generals and military commanders left portraits in those days. In addition to depicting their own forms, they generally reflect their own characteristics in the background. For example, Takeda Shingen's portrait is set on the red lotus fire, which looks more like Ranasa, Harraca.

It seems that Shang Shan's portrait is intended for Takeda. It is probably logical that he chose the shape of Bishamon Day. Strangely, however, in this portrait, Chinobu Uesugi stands in the clouds with an iron bar-these are traditional religious figures, but a crimson wooden cup is painted at his feet.

Why draw a wooden cup for no reason?

It is mentioned in the old saying that in that era, bottles were used to symbolize men, while cups were metaphors of women. ...

Drawing a cup on her portrait can probably reflect the painful psychology of Shangshan's sister. Her gender consciousness has not disappeared, but has been forcibly suppressed. "

Not to mention this statement. None of the portraits of famous soldiers in the Warring States period were painted by themselves. How can there be "metaphor" and "hint"? And just relying on a "cup" is considered a female hint. This is an orphan card, and it's only nine Niu Yi cents.

False statement 6: high? Short?

The myth says, "This is a very interesting thing. One of the problems in the study of Shangshan is whether he is tall or short. "

Even modern popular novels have two versions. Both Tian と Di と written by Masagoro of Haiyin Temple and Upper Qian Shan Heart written by Nanjo Yukio all say that the mark is short, while Jin Benyang's Wu Shen Order says that the mark is big.

These writers are not talking nonsense. There are related ancient military records or essays for reference.

There seems to have been different opinions about whether Kenshin is tall or short.

Basically, according to research, the height of Shang Shan Qian Xin is 5 feet 2 inches, which is about 156 cm. No matter what the standards of the times are, they are really not tall. However, there are many records in ancient books that Kenshin is "high".

Why? In fact, it is easy to explain, because these authors may know that Kenshin is actually a woman. A woman 1.56 meters, definitely tall in Japan during the Warring States period. "

According to the clothes collected by Kenshin in some Japanese Uesugi shrines, the height of Uesugi Shinbu is about 5 feet 2 3 inches (up and down 15Xcm).

At that time, the Japanese were not tall, so maybe that height was "high" at that time. As for the writing and creation of modern novelists, they all read historical materials, speculate and have their own ideas. They regard the novelist's writing as a fact and speculate at will, which is a pseudo-theory.

False Theory 7: The Secret of Kenshin's Body Being Moved and Buried.

Rumor said: "In the Uesugi Kagekatsu era, with the order of Hideyoshi, Shangshan was forced to leave the country that had ruled for many years and turn to Huijin. Later, after Guanyuan, Konka ordered that Mize be sealed instead.

Strangely, every time they move, the Shangshan family will dig up Kenshin's grave, take out the jar containing Kenshin's body, take it away with them and bury it in a new territory.

Why is this? According to the custom at that time, the graves of ancestors could not be easily moved, otherwise it would be unfilial and disrespectful.

The only explanation: Kenshin's body has a big secret, and Shangshan's family should always keep this secret with them, and they are not allowed to leave their control.

What secret? Are you stupid? Don't you get it after reading so much? Because Uesugi Kenshin is a woman. In the Tokugawa era, I especially liked to find fault with the heritage and waste my name. If the Tokugawa shogunate had known that the Shangshan family was a woman, it would have been a disaster. This matter is more urgent than life. Of course, you can't be sloppy. "

Here, without careful consideration, Tokugawa Ieyasu took many measures to weaken the famous governors at that time, such as "taking turns to participate in the pilgrimage system". Celebrities kept going back and forth between the station and Edo, so they didn't have time to sacrifice in other places, so it was convenient to move the remains of their ancestors to the station.

What is said here is a rumor that deliberately misleads the direction of thinking and deliberately pierces the marginal notes. It is a false statement.

Pseudo-theory 8: Kenshin, a delicate scholar and poet

According to this myth, "Kenshin's handwriting has been handed down from generation to generation. Judging from the existing handwriting, it is quite slender, in contrast to Takeda Shingen's vigorous and powerful calligraphy. It can even be said that if the handwriting is written by a man, Kenshin's handwriting is a little too delicate and feminine, unlike a well-known star in all directions.

Not only calligraphy, but also Kenshin's cultural taste is very special.

The Tale of Genji was rarely read by military commanders in the Warring States at that time, and was even disliked by military commanders in the Warring States, because it was a story about love, which had nothing to do with martial arts and even contradicted it. Reading is understandable, and it is normal for people like Imagawa Yoshimoto to read, but can you imagine that Kenshin, who is famous for his martial arts, is also a fan of this way? Unfortunately, in fact, Kenshin is not only a fan of Tale of Genji, but also seems to be a textbook he read since he was a child. This ..... Kenshin's childhood education is very feminine.

When Qian Xin wrote a letter to Luo, he asked his predecessor for a set of songs, "Three Intellectuals Copy", which was quite unexpected at that time. After the Vietnam War, Daming (a hillbilly) in Tian She actually played the song of peace and sought to collect the song of peace famous for its style of Song of Songs (love songs)? ! Judging from Kenshin's cultural style and taste, it can at least be said to be a serious femininity, or a kind of "graceful and restrained" ...

Anyway, I didn't see' unruly'. "

This is even more nonsense. Take China ancient literature as an example. The mainstream of China's literary world is "graceful and restrained school", and literature such as Poems Always in My Heart is written by men. Therefore, what is said here is a rumor that deliberately misleads the direction of thinking and deliberately digs into the marginal notes, which is false.

Pseudo-saying 9: The appearance described by "Li" in Song Ping Ji

According to this myth, "Song Ping's story describes in detail what Kenshin looked like before he died. There is such a description:' Ministers are all beaming when they see the Lord's Prince' (for the sake of understanding, it is untranslated in one place), which is the reaction of ministers when Kenshin was made up by his wife before his death.

It is said that it means "Yuan?な", that is, to write the resurrection of the mark, but the same word can also be written as "Li". In that case, it will be after the ministers are formed. It's too much to use "Li" to describe a man's appearance, unless it's used to describe a feminine man like, longevity, which is actually used here.

It seems that 48-year-old Kenshin was very attractive even on his deathbed. I just don't know if she is attracted to women or ... men. "

Gossip, on the other hand, is deliberately choosing a translation that is beneficial to you. Here, he should choose to translate "Yuan?な". "Ministers are beaming when they see Shang Shan's sincere spirit and radiant face." The gossip here deliberately misleads the direction of thinking and deliberately pierces the marginal notes, which is wrong.

Error Theory 10: Communication in Kenshin

Rumor has it: "When Qian wrote Luo, he visited the residence of General Ashikaga many times. On several occasions, I went into Ashikaga's inner room without Yi Hui present, and talked with his mother and wife, and the relationship was quite close. In this respect, the mothers and wives of Kenshin, Yi Hui and Yi Hui are as usual.

Kenshin does have a good friendship with Yi Hui, but no matter how good a friend he is, he often hangs out with other people's mothers, wives and other women. Anyway, it's just too hard, isn't it? However, neither the general himself nor his wife expressed any dissatisfaction with this, and even thought it was a natural thing.

This may be because Kenshin has told General Ashikaga's wife: We are of the same sex, so we naturally have no psychological discomfort.

Besides, Kenshin is not a stingy person, but when he went to Los Angeles, he didn't send any gifts or even have any contact with female officials in the palace. At that time, the Diary of Tang Dian left by the female official recorded the daily itinerary of Shangshan Shangluo in detail, and there was nothing but meeting the emperor and generals.

This is not normal either. Everyone knows the importance of these women in the palace. Later, Nohiko Oda went to Los Angeles, and Hideyoshi stayed in Kyoto, which was good for the palace, except for two. Kenshin, as the chief commander, should have easily won the favor of female officials, thus winning many additional reputations. But he seems to deliberately avoid these, which is more or less related to his female psychology? "

Here, gossip deliberately misleads the direction of thinking and deliberately exploits the loophole of connection. Here, I don't know the character of Sugiyama Kenshin, but it's okay for Kenshin to mix with other people's mothers, wives and other Harlem, and it doesn't prove to be honest, so as to reassure others.

Mistake 11: Kenshin's psychological cleanliness.

Gossip Notes: "When we gradually discover Kenshin's true colors, we can more and more understand why he is so incompatible with Takeda Shingen in emotional character.

Takeda Shingen is unjust, cruel and lewd. Shang Shan seems particularly disgusted with his lewdness and unethical behavior. Didn't he say that? Chasing after his father and killing his brother-in-law is still a necessity as a person in troubled times, but adultery with his niece is against human relations and an animal. This is absolutely not allowed!

Unjust or even unfilial, that is to say, lewdness is absolutely unacceptable' evil', what a strong female love-hate relationship! "

Kenshin has the name of integrity, benevolence and righteousness, and Kenshin has the mistake of scolding Xin Xuan, which is not only lewd. Here, it is a rumor that deliberately misleads the direction of thinking and deliberately leads the needle. This is a false statement.

Pseudo-Twelve: Statue of Baishan Shrine

It is said: "The White Mountain Temple in Yuehou is dedicated to heaven, but strangely, this statue is a goddess riding a horse with a Ba flag hanging next to it.

Self-proclaimed "paradise in Bishamon", Uesugi Kenshin allowed the female God Bishamon to exist in her own country? "

The fact is that the gods of this shrine are men and women, not just goddesses. Here, it is a rumor that deliberately misleads the direction of thinking and deliberately leads the needle. This is a false statement.

False Thirteen: Kenshin, a transvestite.

What is the most famous style in Kenshin? Wrapped in a headscarf, this was the dress used by women at that time. In addition, there is a "snow coat with red background, willow lapels, and tree trunks dyed with flowers" in Shangshan Temple, which is said to be the clothes that Kenshin wore before his death.

This is even more bullshit. At that time, Japan's most famous opposite sex fetish was "Oda Nobu", and it was even more arbitrary to judge gender by clothes alone. What is said here is that gossip misled us with one-sided historical materials, which is untrue.

Chinobu Uesugi (1530 February 18- 1578 April 19) was a famous figure who was active in Japan during the Warring States Period. After that, the long tail of the guardian generation was Jing Youzi, nicknamed "Tiger Chiyo", and was called Long Tail Wang Hu in adulthood. Because he inherited the name "Shangshan" from Guanling in Kanto, and was given the name by Ashikaga Yi Hui, the constitutional leader of Guanshangling Mountain in Kanto and the shogunate general in Muromachi, he was also called Shangshan hu zheng and Shangshan Hu Hui, and became a Buddhist monk, named Kenshin. Because of Kenshin's high military command ability, he was called the Dragon after the Vietnam War by later generations, and he was also known as the military god, and was famous for his heroic deeds. The official position was "from five members", and after his death, Emperor Meiji posthumously awarded these two players. Kenshin has four adopted sons, namely Uesugi Kagekatsu, Shangshan Jinghu, Zheng Fan, Zhang Shang and Shanpu Guo Jing.

Common name: Shangsan Chinobo

Former names: Long Tail Jinghu, Shangshan Jinghu, Tiger Chiyo.

Title: Dragon after Leap

Gender: historically confirmed as male. However, many contemporary ACG works like to spoof Kenshin, such as Lance in Warring States Policy and Wandering Wild Hope 13- Paradise.

Birth and death: 1530, February 18 (three years in Shandong) ~ 1578, April 19 (six years in heaven)

Occupation: Name

Achievements: Five battles in Sichuan, the battle of taking Sichuan with bare hands, the legendary automobile suspension.

Transfer from post bar.