Who is more powerful in fencing, Sun Shangxiang or Liu Bei?

Liu Bei's fencing is no match for Sun Shangxiang. It is not good for Liu Bei to marry this wife. He is too martial arts, unreasonable and nervous to sleep. Sun Shangxiang is a spoiled child. When he was in Wu, he was spoiled by his mother and brother. Instead of learning piano, chess, calligraphy and painting like other ladies, he practiced martial arts and swords every day like a boy. Although his master is not recorded in the history books, he is definitely the first master of Wu. Although she is a woman, a famous teacher pointed out that 20 years of kung fu is not for nothing, and fencing should surpass the general generals, and it should be no problem to rank second.

Although Liu Bei sells straw sandals, he has a restless heart. When he was a child, he pointed to the canopy and said, "I am the son of heaven, so I should take this hood."

He also likes to learn martial arts and knows a lot about fencing. In the Ming Dynasty, chinese odyssey's five swordsmanship methods were recorded in "Market Town": "the method of fighting and attacking the border villages, the method of Wang Juzhi's rise and fall, the method of Liu Zhi, the method of lightning and the method of Ma Chao." It can be seen that Liu Bei's swordsmanship is brilliant. After the three vows in Taoyuan, local tyrant Zhang Fei created a pair of double swords for it, which was even more powerful.

Why did Liu Bei choose to use a sword? Because he has an advantage over others in playing sword. Liu Beisheng is a little anti-ancestor, "hands over knees" and his arms are much longer than others. As the saying goes, an inch is long and an inch is strong. Liu Bei's arm is more than an inch long, so he has an advantage with a sword.

Although Sun Shangxiang is good at fencing, she is inferior to Liu Bei in three aspects.

One is strength. Men and women are different. If they are equal in fencing, strength and physical strength, Sun Shangxiang will suffer a big loss.

Second, there are great differences in actual combat experience. Although Sun Shangxiang has been practicing fencing for 20 years, he has never been on the battlefield. Liu Bei has been through many battles. The History of the Three Kingdoms records: "General He Jin sent Qiu, a captain, to recruit soldiers, and his ancestors followed him until he met a thief in Xiapi." "Plain Liu Ziping knew he had martial arts. When Zhang Chun rebelled, Qingzhou was called and sent for purity. "It also recorded the story of Liu Bei tying Du You up and beating him up. The Romance of the Three Kingdoms has a colorful description of "Three Britain vs. Lu Bu", so Liu Bei has an advantage in actual combat experience.

The third point is that these two apes have long arms. It is estimated that if they held out their hands, Sun Shangxiang couldn't get close to him.

Although Liu Bei has great advantages in fencing, it is a piece of cake for Sun Shangxiang to kill Liu Bei. Because Sun Shangxiang is used to charm, all the maids around her have martial arts. When Liu Bei entered the bridal chamber, he saw that all the maids around him were wearing broadswords, which almost scared him to pee. Other people's knives and axes are lurking behind the screen, and the killer here is not an idle generation. Thanks to the housekeeper's early years, Liu Bei returned to normal physiology.

After all, they are husband and wife and should share the same bed. Sun Shangxiang's bedroom is full of weapons, and he really wants to kill him. After Liu Bei fell asleep, he grabbed the guy and put Liu Bei on the bed.

But Sun Shangxiang doesn't like this old man who is almost two rounds old, but she doesn't want to be a widow. She never wanted to kill Liu Bei.

However, Liu Bei is not practical in his heart, and he can't sleep well when he marries a wife with high martial arts. Others are happy when they get married. He was so nervous that he had to build a city in Liling, west of Jingzhou Public Security Bureau, so that Sun Shangxiang and her guards could live in a small kingdom. This city was later called "Liling City" or "Mrs. Sun City".

Speaking of swords, of course, Liu Bei is awesome.

Liu Bei's martial arts are seriously underestimated. Perhaps Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are too fierce, but Liu Bei generally does not act rashly, so that many people think that Liu Bei is a weak scholar with no hands. Holding a sword is also an ostentation.

In fact, Liu Bei's martial arts should be very strong. At the beginning, there were only 500 people under Liu Bei, and Liu Bei had to go into battle himself. Although he fought against the Yellow Scarf Army, he was able to charge with a knife, which showed that Liu Bei was still very effective. After all, it's an inch short.

When the Three Kingdoms beat Lu Bu, Liu Bei dared to beat Lu Bu himself. When Bowangpo was burned, Liu Bei personally challenged Xia Houdun.

All these show that Liu Bei's swordsmanship is quite powerful. It passed the test of life and death on the battlefield.

Although Sun Shangxiang also knows fencing, he has no actual combat experience, and he only plays with his female soldiers at ordinary times. Can he practice real kung fu? Certainly no match for Liu Bei.

In fact, the husband and wife turned against each other in the Jianghu. There is no "fencing" at all, just a word, desperately meet each other. So who is better, Sun Shangxiang or Liu Bei? Ladies and gentlemen, listen to me slowly. Wonderful, hehe! .......

First, Miss Sun's strength with "seven weapons" is unfathomable.

These seven weapons are: sword, skill, hate, servant, affection, stratagem and life.

First, the sword

The so-called "sword" is actually a dagger, a birthday gift from my father Sun Jian to my only daughter, an artifact on earth, a "fish-gut sword"; Cut iron like mud and seal your throat with blood.

Second, art.

After Sun Jian married a strange girl, Wu, she had four boys and one girl. Wu was born in a bitter family, lost his parents, and looked handsome. When Sun Shangxiang grew up, she listened to her mother's orders and learned martial arts from her eldest brother Sun Ce, so she was good at unarmed combat.

Third, hate.

Qi died of illness, and the group pushed down the ancestors for Jingzhou animal husbandry public security. The right side is a little scared, and my sister is very practical. My late master went to Beijing to see the power, and he was ready to remember it. "(deepen the friendship between relatives)" Biography of the Three Kingdoms "At this time, Liu Bei was over 50 years old, while Sun Shangxiang was only 10 years old. As the first princess of Wudong, such a marriage caused great hatred from Miss Sun. She feels that she has become a victim of politics, and more importantly, she already has a lover in her heart. (Later said)

(Liu Bei Chengdu proclaimed himself emperor)

Fourth, servants

Shizai: Mrs. Sun is the only one? Strong and brave, with the wind of brotherhood, there are more than 100 maids around, all standing by themselves with knives. Every time Liu Bei enters the customs, he often feels awe in his heart.

Verb (short for verb) emotion

"If they don't bring their lovers into their rooms?" However, since the eldest brother's daughter married Lu Xun and became her niece, the younger sister-in-law has often "looked at the water" and paid attention to makeup. At family gatherings, Sun Xiaogu secretly loved scholar-bureaucrat Lu Xun and occasionally revealed it.

An intransitive verb scheming.

Miss Sun's heart is like Cheng in The Legend of Flying Fox and The Condor Heroes. Because of love, she plans how to murder her husband every day.

Seven, life

Or Zhuge Liang later told the Shu generals about Liu Bei's situation at that time: "When the master (Liu Bei) was in public security, he was afraid that Cao Gong would be stronger in the north and Sun Quan would advance eastward, and recently he was afraid that Mrs. Sun would become an elbow; At this time, Mrs. Sun may fight with her life. It should be a pink rose dream, but I was asked to walk on thin ice. Dare Liu Bei show his double-edged sword in the bedroom? In the limited time and space, Sun Shangxiang is a shoo-in!

Concluding remarks

Sun Shangxiang's name was given by later generations. She was originally a lady's family, and her fate was a mystery. It's not surprising that Sun Shangxiang became an internet celebrity after one thousand years because of the polishing of Luo Guanzhong, the author of Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and the Sao editing of an alliance.

Liu Bei's swordsmanship is more mature and stable, suitable for killing enemies, so Liu Bei's swordsmanship is even more powerful! Regardless of the official history or romance, Liu Bei is a master figure, which is incomparable to Mrs. Sun.

But before expounding this issue, we need to make it clear that we make the following statement from the perspective of The Romance of the Three Kingdoms, because there is no such person in the official history, and its prototype is Mrs. Sun.

In The Romance of Three Kingdoms, Sun Shangxiang is Sun Quan's sister. After the end of Battle of Red Cliffs, Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang occupied Jingzhou by stratagem. In order to recapture Jingzhou, Zhou Yu tricked Liu Bei into coming to Jiangdong by pretending to be willing to marry Sun Shangxiang. Under the mastermind of Zhuge Liang, Liu Bei and Zhao Yun went to Jiangdong. At first, Sun Shangxiang didn't know Liu Bei's age. Later, he saw Liu Bei's heroism and admired it. Finally, at Zhuge Liang's three tips, Liu Bei returned to Jingzhou safely with Sun Shangxiang. This is also the story of losing his wife and soldiers.

What is Sun Shangxiang like in romantic stories? How is her fencing? Can she compete with Liu Bei?

1. Zhou Yu wants to cheat Liu Bei with a honey trap, even if he can't kill him, he can kill his will. Under such a purpose, Zhou Yu could only find a woman who would be very attractive in both position and appearance, so Zhou Yu finally proposed to Sun Quan to betroth Sun Shangxiang to Liu Bei. Sure enough, after seeing Sun Shangxiang, Liu Bei forgot all his ambitions and how to destroy Cao Cao. As you can see, Sun Shangxiang is really charming.

There are many beauties in Romance of the Three Kingdoms who are ashamed to spend. Sun Shangxiang is probably the most distinctive one. From an unconventional woman to marrying the emperor, her emotional experience is also quite famous. There have been many famous literati around her, and Zhou Yu and Zhuge Liang fought bravely for her. From the analysis of these details, it can be concluded that Sun Shangxiang is by no means an ordinary woman.

Zhuge Liang, who is both civil and military, heard that Soochow wanted to recruit Liu Bei as a son-in-law, and congratulated him again and again, and soon arranged Zhao Yun's plan to send Liu Bei to Jiangdong. This certainly reflects Zhuge Liang's bold but cautious talent. On the other hand, it can be seen that Zhuge Liang also thinks that Sun Shangxiang is tolerant and talented, worthy of his ambitious master. It is recorded in the article that Sun Shangxiang danced with a sword and played with a gun, while Liu Bei was on vacation in Jiangdong (teasing), he danced and rode horses with Sun Shangxiang every day (really enviable). Finally, when Liu Bei was preparing to travel to and from Jingzhou with Sun Shangxiang and others, he met Zhou Yu's pursuer. At this time, Liu Bei took down the third trick given by Zhuge Liang, in which Zhuge Liang asked Liu Bei to tell Sun Shangxiang, who had been practicing martial arts since childhood, that Sun Shangxiang cursed General Wu Dong and came out to stop the pursuers from protecting his uncle. Visible Sun Shangxiang is really strong-willed, don't lose a man.

In the official history, Fa Zheng once warned Liu Bei not to get too close to Mrs. Sun, on the one hand, because she was from Jiangdong, and on the other hand, because Mrs. Sun was really good at martial arts. But can Sun Shangxiang compare with Liu Bei? The author says that this is totally two levels. Since the Yellow turban insurrectionary uprising, Liu Bei has led Guan Yu and Zhang Fei to kill the enemy, and he is good at double swords. You know, killing the enemy and practicing sword in peace are two different things. After all, Sun Shangxiang is a woman and has never really been on the battlefield. Her fencing level can't compare with Liu Bei! This is my further elaboration on this issue, and I hope it can be passed.

3. Slightly tragic, ending in resentment. The above mentioned about Sun Shangxiang's personality characteristics, now let's analyze what happened to Sun Shangxiang.

Sun Shangxiang is Sun Quan's sister, but in order to win Jingzhou, Sun Quan listened to Zhou Yu's honey trap. Think about it. She's alone. Is it heartless of you to let her marry Liu Bei, an opponent who has entered middle-aged and old age? On the other hand, in order to ease the relationship with Jiangdong, Liu Bei reluctantly married Sun Shangxiang. After returning to Jingzhou, Liu Bei had no intention of staying with Sun Shangxiang, because he was not at ease, because he also wanted to sacrifice everything and seize the world. Alone, he was later cheated back to Jiangdong. This is the story of intercepting the river and catching the sinus. In The Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Sun Shangxiang didn't describe her after she returned to Jiangdong, but it is conceivable that Sun Shangxiang is his wife after all, and life is naturally not as good as before. It is recorded in unofficial history that Sun Shangxiang finally married Lu Xun and had children, and it is also recorded that she threw herself into the river after Liu Bei's death, but no matter which outcome, it was a tragedy for her.

Of course, when we look at history and novels, we should pay attention to the distinction. Sun Shangxiang mentioned above is different from the official history from the angle of romance, but whether it is romance or history, Mrs Sun is a legend.

I don't know, it's not described in the annals of the Three Kingdoms or the Romance of the Three Kingdoms.

Only Liu Bei saw that his and Sun Xiaomei's bridal chamber was full of weapons, so he moved them away. In the process, let Sun Xiaomei's maid be cynical.

The introduction of Sun Quan's sister occupies a small proportion in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms. In the above paragraph, Liu Bei entered the bridal chamber and saw that the maids were all wearing swords and hanging swords, and the swords and guns on both sides of the room were arranged, which made him pale.

He was eclipsed, not necessarily because he was afraid of how powerful Sun Xiaomei was, but because he didn't understand him and felt afraid of him when designing Soochow.

As for their fencing, who is better?

In my opinion, if this is a performance, it must be Sun Xiaomei. After all, girls' sword dancing is more ornamental. But in actual combat, I'm afraid Liu Bei is even worse.

After all, Liu Bei, as a veteran, has been fighting for half his life since he suppressed the yellow turban insurrectionary uprising.

In this half-life, he once fought against Lu Bu with Zhang Fei and Guan Yu. Under his sword, he also killed many thieves.

There is such a passage in the reflection:

These two paragraphs reveal two messages: Liu Bei and Mrs. Sun are not as loving as they are in romance novels; (Afraid that Mrs. Sun will be born under the elbow and armpit) Liu Bei is very afraid of this lady (the late master is always sincere every time he enters).

So many people speculate that Liu Bei can't beat this lady? Is fencing inferior to Mrs. Sun?

Actually, it's not. Mrs. Sun's swordsmanship may have been learned from everyone, but she has a special position and has not been tested in actual combat. In Wu Dong, everyone made way for her. Even if there was a combat drill, there was no decent opponent, and people didn't really fight her. Swordsmanship without actual combat is not a great fencing at all.

Liu Bei's swordsmanship is said to be under the guidance of Wang Yue, a great swordsman at the end of Han Dynasty. Whether you are a fencing master or not, Liu Bei is different from Cao in actual combat. Liu Bei often goes into battle in disguise, and the sword goes sideways on the battlefield. No one gives up on you.

Isn't there a saying in the kung fu circle? It is said that "the weapon is strange, and the death is fast." Weapon monsters, who were not killed on the battlefield, show that they are all capable people. During the Three Kingdoms period, people used long weapons in real-time combat. Liu Bei should be the only one who uses short weapons such as double swords. Liu Bei suffered many defeats and wars, and he could survive without a decent good horse (there was no horse before he settled in Jingzhou). It shows that Liu Bei's martial arts is very awesome. It may not be as tough as Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, but it is no problem to rank among the second-rate military commanders in the Three Kingdoms. One is full of style, the other is a veteran, with high and low judgment.

The political marriage between Liu Bei and Mrs. Sun is not as beautiful as in romance novels. Mrs. Sun is a military commander and is often accompanied by a maid-in-waiting with a knife. She was spoiled in Dongwu before, and no one said that she married Liu Bei after all. Everyone must be afraid. If she is stabbed in her sleep, who can stand it?

So it's not that Liu Bei can't beat Mrs. Sun. On the one hand, good men don't fight with women, on the other hand, couples don't fight with swords every day. Mrs. Sun didn't persuade her to restrain herself, but Liu Bei simply broke up with her, without any trouble. When Fazheng invited him to go to Sichuan, he immediately fled with his troops. Since then, the two have never met again.

Mrs. Sun's temper is too strong for Liu Bei to like. In this case, it is impossible to leave a son and a half women. It can be said that it is very tragic. Daughter's home, it is best to be virtuous and virtuous (not to say that you can't be martial, score occasions). You see, after Liu Bei entered Sichuan, he married Mrs. Wu (Wu Yi's sister) very well and gave birth to two sons.

It must be Liu Bei. First, after all, Liu Bei is a person, or a person whose force is out of control. He is an absolute winner in strength. As the saying goes, he can lose ten skills in one hand. Second, he can judge the level from the weapons used by both sides, and the skills of people who can use double swords should not be underestimated. Therefore, Sun Shangxiang, that is, dancing sword at home, is ok, but it is not enough to really charge and kill the enemy on the battlefield.

Liu Bei's early swordsmanship was also quite good. There shouldn't be too many people in the Three Kingdoms who can compete with Lu Bu. Besides, people who can be locked up, recognized by Zhang and respected as big brothers must have something extraordinary. Although Sun Shangxiang comes from a noble family, she is a woman and has never been on the battlefield. How can she compare with Liu Bei?

Liu Bei's weapon in Romance of the Three Kingdoms is a double-edged sword, also called Yuanyang Sword. It is composed of two very similar swords, and * * uses the same scabbard. Among them, Yuanyang Sword (male sword) is three feet seven inches long, with a contract of 0.85 meters, and weighs seven pounds and three ounces, while Yuanyang Sword (female sword) is three feet four inches long, about 0.78 meters, and weighs six pounds and four ounces.

In other words, these two swords are less than one meter long, so they are short weapons. There is no record of Liu Bei's long weapon in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. In the three wars of the British army against Lu Bu, Liu Bei joined hands with Guan Yu and Zhang Fei to fight against Lu Bu. In the three British wars, Lyu3 bu4 was a horse war, and the horse war usually took long weapons.

Double-stranded sword

For example, Lu Bu's square painting halberd is 2.36 meters long, Guan Yu's dragon crescent moon blade is 2.24 meters long, Zhang Fei's Zhang Ba snake spear is 2.49 meters long, and Liu Bei's double-edged sword is less than 1 meter. Lu Bu can attack Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei at a distance of one or two meters, and Guan Yu and Zhang Fei can also fight back at a distance of one or two meters. Only Liu Bei can attack within one meter of Lu Bu.

In other words, because Liu Bei is a short soldier, it is difficult to attack Lu Bu. At best, Liu Bei is a trumpeter, just encirclement and suppression of Lu Bu, but then again, an inch is a danger. Liu Bei can fight Lu Bu with short weapons. Unless he was too strong, he would have been stabbed to death by Lu Bu with a halberd.

Therefore, it can be confirmed from the side that Liu Bei's force is not weak. Lu Bu killed Fang Yue in five rounds, Mu Shun in 1 round, Wu Anguo's wrist in 10 round, and Gongsun Zan in several rounds. Liu Bei teamed up with Guan Yu and Zhang Fei to beat Lu Bu, and finally defeated Lu Bu. Therefore, Liu Bei is not as strong as Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, but he is also a second-rate military commander.

Three heroes against Lu Bu

Liu Bei's force can probably rank in the top 30 or so of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. After all, he can be with superb military commanders like Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun and Ma Chao. If Liu Bei doesn't have a killer weapon, it will be difficult to convince the public, especially Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, who are so conceited that few people in the whole world can value them. Zhang Fei always singled out Lu Bu, while Guan Yu looked down on everyone except Lu Bu.

In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Liu Bei's martial arts can probably be similar to that of Hua Xiong and Coss, because Liu Bei used a double-edged sword, so fencing should be good.

Mrs. Sun is Sun Quan's sister and Liu Bei's wife. After Battle of Red Cliffs, Sun Quan married his sister to Liu Bei in order to win him over. When Liu Bei went to Soochow to propose marriage, he personally waved a double-edged sword and split the stone in half with one sword. It can be seen that Liu Bei's sword is not only a sword but also brave.

Liu Bei

However, Mrs. Sun in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is very skilled in martial arts. She learned fencing from an early age and often played fencing with her maid. Mrs. Sun's maids are standing on both sides of the bedroom with swords, and Liu Bei will be frightened every time he enters the bedroom. She thought it was an ambush set by Soochow, and she could keep an eye on Liu Bei at any time, so Liu Bei was actually afraid of Mrs. Sun.

However, Liu Bei's fear is different from that on the battlefield. Just like people who are afraid of their wives are not afraid of others in practical work, although Mrs. Sun knows how to use a sword and there is no actual combat experience in the romance of the Three Kingdoms, Liu Bei is different. Liu Bei started from actual combat for many years and lived a life of licking blood with a knife.

Liu Bei and Mrs. Sun

Therefore, judging from the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Liu Bei's martial arts is definitely higher than Mrs. Sun's, and his fencing is also higher than Mrs. Sun's. Actual combat experience is the most important to martial arts, and Liu Bei is obviously more powerful.

But Liu Bei in history is more powerful than Liu Bei in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, because Liu Bei is one of the five great swordsmen in ancient China. According to Sun Tzu's Art of War, written by the guerrilla general He during the Jiajing period of Ming Dynasty:

Chen Ji is a gauntlet, a gauntlet about exercises and battles. This book specifically mentions the five swordsmen in ancient China, namely: Bian Zhuangzi's fighting method, Wang Juzhi's rising and falling method, Liu Bei's Gu Ying method, Ma Ming's lightning method and Ma Chao's fighting method. These five swordsmanship have their own biographies.

Liu Bei and Mrs. Sun

Liu Bei's swordsmanship is Gu Ying, which is a double sword. The so-called Gu Ying is both offensive and defensive. The operation is to hold the sword in one hand, watch (attack) with the left hand, and watch (defend) with the right hand, so as to ensure that one hand attacks and the other hand guards at any time.

If the record is true, Liu Bei can also be called a fencing master, just like the warrior Malik Chao. In addition, there are records about Liu Bei:

The so-called Dian lue is a unofficial history written by Yu Qian, a historian of Wei in the Three Kingdoms period. It was written by Yu Qian copying historical materials of the pre-Qin period. Yu Qian is also the author of "Lulve" and should be credible. This means that Liu Ziping, a plain person, knows that Liu Bei is brave and brave, so Liu Ziping called Liu Bei and led the army together.

Liu Bei

There is no record of Liu Bei's martial arts or fencing in the official history of the Three Kingdoms, but judging from Liu Bei's experience, his force will definitely be high. Liu Bei participated in the Yellow Scarf Uprising in his early years and defeated the Yellow Scarf Army. Later, he began to lead his team to start a business. Although Liu Bei's strength is the weakest among all the princes, although Liu Bei has been defeated and all the other princes have been destroyed, only Liu Bei is still alive.

Liu Bei survived not only with the help of Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, but also with great courage. Otherwise, how can he win a generation of battles in troubled times without getting hurt? This is Liu Bei's specialty, and because Liu Bei, as the leader of a political power, neglected his force. In fact, Liu Bei's force is not much different from Guan Yu and Zhang Fei in the official history. Otherwise, how can a weak Liu Bei keep Guan Yu and Zhang Fei loyal?

Although Liu Bei in the official history was also afraid of Mrs. Sun, the Romance of the Three Kingdoms recorded that Liu Bei was afraid of Mrs. Sun's elbow system at home. Everyone can understand this fear, but she doesn't want to care. Although Mrs. Sun in the official history has also practiced martial arts and used swords and guns, she is not at the same level as Liu Bei and is far from being Liu Bei's opponent. Of course, Liu Bei is even worse.

If you are all fine, don't be serious.