Is the school's "free broken mobile phone" management method appropriate?

I think the school's management method of breaking mobile phones for free is a humorous statement, and then the purpose is to deter students from carrying mobile phones without permission. But if it is really implemented, it is unreasonable. Let me first talk about why I said that the management method of free mobile phones is unreasonable.

First of all, mobile phones are students' private property. Even if students carry mobile phones privately, which violates the rules and regulations of the school, they should not use this radical method to destroy other people's private property. Although when I was in junior high school, the school's measures to manage mobile phones were also very strict. Once discovered, they will be confiscated and can only be recovered after graduation. By then, these confiscated mobile phones may be scrapped due to long-term power failure. However, the school has not directly damaged the students' property, so we will be afraid of the school's practice and abide by this rule. It can be seen that a lighter punishment can bring political review to students, and there is no need to destroy their private property.

Secondly, directly smashing students' mobile phones is easy to cause students' anger, which is counterproductive and divides schools and students into opposing camps. In fact, I am more concerned about whether the school's management method of smashing mobile phones for free will really be implemented on students, or just talk about it, or give students a chance to turn over a new leaf once or twice? In my mind, it is inappropriate to smash students' mobile phones, no matter whether they are given a chance to mend their ways or not, how many times they are given a chance to mend their ways.

In order to manage a school well, instead of relying on strict regulations to restrain students or intimidating them with horrible punishment, it is better to let students sincerely recognize the school and be willing to follow normal campus rules for the sake of collective honor and personal future. Campus management methods such as smashing mobile phones are still less common.