Gao He, who is the real genius?

About "Who is the real genius, Ma Weidou or Hegao?" This question, Bian Xiao sorted out the user's answers from multiple channels, so that everyone can understand it more comprehensively.

1. The following opinions were praised by 367 people and discussed on 108:

Three people have their own merits, and they are all learned people. However, can we think that Gao was born in a high-level intellectual family, and he was top student himself, so when he was studying in thousands of books and Wan Li Road, he could be exposed to some high-level or internal news? What he reflects is a kind of madness in the bones of intellectuals. Liang Hongda, a river's lake background, is proficient in everything and knows the way of the world in China society. It's not bookish, it's Jianghu. Ma Weidou is self-taught. He has read many books and met many people. He feels that there is a bandit spirit or some kind of detachment in his bones. He knows China society. He can participate or watch. He can retreat or defend.

2. The following opinions were praised by 70 people and exchanged and discussed for 26 times:

Often watch three-person talk shows. Gao's personal design is in line with his family background of higher vocational education, top student background and study abroad background. Liang Hongda's personnel are in line with his career as a news commentator, and his narration and comments are in place. Some people think that Ma Weidou has a mass at the right hypochondrium, which, in the present words, means pretending to be forced. In fact, these piques are only part of his life experience. Ma Weidou's personality conforms to his status as a collector of cultural relics. He once worked as an editor of a publishing house and a screenwriter of a TV series. High and no ranking is required. They have different identities, do their own jobs or go their own ways. The theory of gifted scholars is generally the judgment of future generations on past lives, the meaning of beautification and praise, and the affirmation of future generations. Of course, there must be a lot of artistic processing and word-of-mouth distortion of the parties, so contemporary people are rarely called gifted scholars. If we have to talk about the talents in the current cultural circle and entertainment circle, it may be Zhou Libo who claims to be a talent. Nail yourself to the wall before you die. As for whether such a person is a real genius, I have reservations, at least to prove that he has no wisdom to set up a monument without words! Liang Hongda and Gao are not gifted scholars, but we can say for sure that these three people are all horns! (Ju), a northern dialect, is often used to address people with status, status and ability in the industry in the late Qing Dynasty and early Republic of China, which is the third title. Anyone who knows traditional culture and language knows that the name Jiao is not used by ordinary people!

3. The following opinions were praised by 35 people and exchanged and discussed for 28 times:

Only by knowing what "talent" is can we objectively judge who is a real genius. Wit, it doesn't matter whether you like it or not; It has nothing to do with his popularity, fame and influence. To define "talent", we must first understand "A". A, 10, the original meaning of coinage is: the two are crossed, that is, they are completely matched. The core wisdom of China culture is that only when everything is perfectly matched can the best objective results be produced. Therefore, A stands for the best, the first best, Grade A and Grade A in China culture. Perfect matching means that your words and deeds conform to the overall needs and the law of objective discovery, which objectively has indeed produced good and long-term beneficial effects and results for everyone. Talent is infinitely close to "A" from below, so the original meaning of coinage is: infinitely close to the objective needs of the present. For example, just now, talents, talents, etc. Are very close to the current point. No matter how good your technology is, it doesn't meet the demand. Heroes are useless and have no talent. Therefore, words and deeds are more reliable and objective, which is indeed conducive to the current general good and long-term good. This is really "talented". Therefore, being truly talented has nothing to do with being eloquent, having a unique point of view, being difficult to distinguish between true and false, and being popular. We can see that Lao Liang is good at description and expression, Gao is good at looking at problems from another angle, and is good at presenting truth and falsehood. They all have their own attractions. But these three are not good at talking about universality and regularity, and objectively do not play much role in universality and long-term good. So according to the definition of China traditional culture, they really don't belong to real talents.

4. The following opinions were praised by 23 people, and 1 1 was exchanged and discussed:

Liang Hongda is knowledgeable and experienced. Seeing the world from a height is insightful; Go deep into the core to see the problem and have discernment; Have the ability to solve problems with conscience. He has a good personality, a good knowledge and a good network connection. Ranked first among all famous mouths, there should not be much controversy. The subject asked who is the real talent, just because there are many divisions of experience in the years on the spot. Such as wizards, geniuses, generalists, talents, mediocrity, wasting talents and so on. Let me divide it. Liang Hongda and others are wizards. However, there is specialization in the art because people are different. Ma Weidou is proficient in culture and art, and has long been cultivated as the embodiment of traditional humanities. I am full of benevolence and cynicism. The performance on the network is to transmit positive energy, which is bitter. But he doesn't come from the academic class, and most of his thoughts are those deeply rooted in traditional culture. So there is height and lack of depth. Think highly of it and make no comments.

5. Wonderful answer:

Broadly speaking, that is to say, for the topic they often talk about on TV, Mr. Ma Weidou, whether he is in the history department of the university or has entered the university. He is my most respected scholar who studies the medieval history and modern history of China. He is very convincing about the characteristics of ancient cultural relics corresponding to this historical period. Historical research has its particularity, that is, theory is more than practice. Almost all the bases of idealism and subjective judgment come from history books. Therefore, due to the lack of practical support, most historical issues are still in the academic state or can not stand scrutiny. Teacher Ma Weidou is characterized by his rigorous academic theory of history. Ma Weidong, a teacher, did her best to study the royal cemetery. On historical issues. He is a critic of the modern history of China and the traditional culture, phenomena and some little-known knowledge of China society, especially the art world, since the reform and opening up. Obviously, he is interested in the history of world military development and war. I prefer Yu Xiansheng, then Mr. Liang, then Mr. Gao. I have three reasons. I learned something from Mr Ma Weidou that I didn't know. More importantly, his meticulous style of study, his adherence to the academic principle of seeking truth from facts, and his scholarly demeanor of never giving in to authority in the face of facts. And what Hegao said: Because we are contemporaries, I can almost find * * * Ming.