How to treat the case of hitting the class teacher in the street 20 years ago and the teacher didn't agree to settle?

I support no reconciliation. It's arrogant for a young man in his prime to beat a helpless old teacher and find someone to make a video for 20 years! Who will be a teacher in the future? I am also a teacher, and I have beaten students. Every time, I raise my hand high and pat the students on the shoulder, saying that it is not easy for my parents to send you to school, but you are hanging around. But now they have all grown up, and now they all go out to different jobs in society. Every Spring Festival, they come to visit my strict teacher who used to beat them. There is a saying: severity is harmful, and it is even more harmful not to fight or scold! In school, dozens of students in a class should be teachers and get along with their classmates on an equal footing, so that students can get close to you and listen to you. I don't think it's right to hit a teacher after 20 years. This parent hasn't realized the mistake of hitting the teacher, so go and reflect!

This problem is more complicated. If you stay out of it, everyone can calm down. Who can be calm in it? ! Therefore, the settlement depends on the ideas of the parties, and it is useless for us to talk more. In this case, my opinion is:

1. It is an ancient tradition and educational behavior for teachers to beat and scold students. After the founding of New China, the state formulated a socialist education policy, which clearly stipulated that teachers should not beat, scold or physically punish students, let alone insult their personality, because teachers and students are politically equal. After the reform and opening up, the state has promulgated a series of laws and regulations, such as the Education Law of the People's Republic of China, which clearly stipulates that students should not be beaten, scolded or physically punished, let alone insulted. For example, Article 29 of the Compulsory Education Law stipulates that teachers should respect students' personality, not discriminate against students, not impose corporal punishment on students, corporal punishment in disguised form or other acts that insult their personal dignity, and not infringe on their legitimate rights and interests. Article 37 of the Teachers Law stipulates that a teacher shall be given administrative sanctions or dismissed by his school or the administrative department of education in any of the following circumstances: (1) deliberately failing to complete the task of education and teaching, causing losses to education and teaching; (two) corporal punishment of students, the education is invalid; (three) bad conduct, insulting students, bad influence. If a teacher falls under any of the circumstances listed in Items (2) and (3) of the preceding paragraph and the circumstances are serious enough to constitute a crime, he shall be investigated for criminal responsibility according to law. Article 21 of the Law on the Protection of Minors stipulates that teachers and staff in schools, kindergartens and nurseries should respect the personal dignity of minors and may not impose corporal punishment, disguised corporal punishment or other acts that insult their personal dignity. Therefore, it should be illegal for a teacher to beat, scold or physically punish his students 20 years ago, or even insult his personality.

2. Theoretically, when students are treated illegally by teachers, such as beating, scolding, corporal punishment, or even insulting their personality, they can fight against teachers with bad ethics according to relevant laws, and they can appeal to the education administrative department or bring a lawsuit directly to the court. However, in real life, there is often only one school in a place. If the student sues the teacher, he may win the lawsuit, but he loses the opportunity to study and even affects his brothers and sisters' chances of going to school. So many students and parents choose to give up their legitimate rights and interests. However, individual schools and relevant education authorities are negligent in management and have not found or discovered teachers' illegal behavior. However, they turn a blind eye to the enrollment rate, college entrance examination admission rate and other achievements, and even recognize and condone the illegal behavior of teachers, resulting in the failure to effectively safeguard the legitimate rights and interests of students.

Third, because the legitimate rights and interests of students have not been safeguarded, the knot has not been opened, so that after 20 years, there is an excessive act of beating teachers. Although everything happens for a reason, this kind of violence against violence is definitely wrong and cannot be advocated and supported, especially if the video of beating a teacher is posted online, the impact will be extremely bad.

To sum up, it is wrong for students to beat teachers after 20 years, and it should be dealt with according to law. Twenty years ago, teachers beat and scolded students, and even insulted personal dignity. This is a fact and illegal. Although the retrospective period of the law has passed, they should also apologize to the students. Compared with teachers and schools, students and parents are vulnerable groups. Although there are many legal provisions to protect the legitimate rights and interests of students, it is difficult to implement them in place. It is suggested that the relevant departments revise and refine the legal provisions full of ideals and realistic feelings. It is suggested that schools and education authorities should establish a correct view of political achievements, establish and improve a scientific education evaluation system and a supervision and management system for teachers' teaching management, earnestly safeguard and protect the legitimate rights and interests of students and avoid the recurrence of similar incidents.

My opinion is also uncompromising. It is against human ethics that such a thing should happen.

Respecting teachers and attaching importance to teaching is the fashion of the whole society. As an engineer of human soul, a teacher is a profession that affects life with life. Teachers, regardless of their abilities, want to do their best to train their children well. When dealing with some Xiong Haizi, in order to make them become talents in the future, we racked our brains to fight with the children, in order to send the students to a higher school safely and healthily. Everyone is successful under the education of teachers. Therefore, respecting teachers is a person's duty and also reflects a person's self-cultivation.

The teacher in the incident may not have done a good job in ideological work when dealing with students' problems, which led to being hated by this student for more than 20 years. Over time, hatred is not indifferent, but magnified countless times, so big that as an adult in his 30 s, he dared to fight with a kind and elderly teacher. Is it a person? No, once a teacher, always a father. Bite back is the real version of the farmer and the snake. He doesn't know that it is responsibility and love to the teacher at first; His hands are made of animals.

If a person doesn't think about distant things, he will find sadness close at hand. Teachers are considerate of students before they dare to be strict; Parents consider the long-term for their children, enter famous schools at all costs and find famous teachers. If the teacher sees that the students are naughty and don't study, he will relax and give them freedom. The students are very comfortable, but is there a future? Therefore, teachers are responsible teachers and students are psychologically distorted students. When meeting such students, does the teacher hide or not? It's really hard to choose.

Mediation will encourage students' arrogance, so this kind of thing may happen again. No reconciliation is the second education. School education is not good, but there is strict education.

Those who beat teachers must be investigated for criminal responsibility according to law and sentenced to several years in prison to educate future generations. Some students can be said to be running amok at school, bullying the small with the big, charging protection fees to classmates, ignoring teachers and so on. Such people must be punished or taught a lesson so that they can learn from each other. A bad student can minimize the academic performance of the whole class, ruin a class and lead students to transfer. The teacher dare not take care of it.

Teacher reconciliation is not supported.

This case is different from ordinary civil cases. Beating people illegally is the most basic common sense, and mediation can solve it. However, the hitter recorded the live video of beating the teacher and posted it online, which is a very bad public opinion orientation. If it was a personal act to hit the head teacher in the street 20 years ago, the teacher can forgive him for his lax teaching and laziness, which is responsible for his own educational behavior. Often posting videos of beating class teachers on the Internet has seriously hurt teachers' mental health.

These slaps not only hit the head teacher's face, but also hit the faces of teachers all over the country, giving people a kind of teacher to "educate" me, and I will hold a grudge and find a suitable opportunity to "teach" the teacher, so that others can see me and hit the teacher. Now that the teacher is old, what will you do with me? This is a very wrong act of violence, and the teacher's injury is much more serious than those dozens of slaps. Physical injury can be healed quickly, and mental injury may be a lifelong pain.

The hitter told the story of mental injury caused by the teacher 20 years ago. If the teacher has ever hurt Chang, he can often sue the teacher, but it has been 20 years and the statute of limitations has passed. Now it is a fact that the teacher was beaten, and the teacher's spirit was greatly hurt, so he did not support the teacher's reconciliation.

At 9 o'clock this morning, although the case was heard in court, it was not pronounced in court. Judging from the video of the hitter beating the teacher, the facts are conclusive and suspected of constituting the crime of seeking trouble. According to the relevant provisions of the criminal law, if it constitutes the crime of stirring up trouble, the hitter may be sentenced to 1 to 3 years' imprisonment.

No matter what the original reason is, it has been 20 years, and you are an adult. You also know that hitting people is illegal. It is definitely illegal to hit teachers on purpose, and you should be punished, otherwise the world will be in a mess.

From the teacher's point of view, it is normal to hit students at first. Our primary school teacher beat the students so badly that even his nephew made mistakes. The twin grandson of the brigade secretary angered our class teacher. He came to take over and packed it in a few days!

When he comes, he says, either you change, or you leave, or I leave. It was a real fight, and I was so honest!

Our teacher has a high prestige, and everyone is grateful to him. Without his strict discipline, our class would be finished, and the victims were those of us who studied hard, because there was no teacher at that time!

Thus, truth is truth, and law is law. If you want to fight, you must fight. Sometimes, son, fighting is sure to be immediate, as long as you are fair and just.

I don't know why people who beat teachers are beaten at first, but good students are rarely beaten, so there is a reason for being beaten. On the contrary, it should be avoidable. If the hitter is narrow-minded and resentful, after 20 years, the teacher can appropriately explain to the teacher that he was young and energetic, and this matter will pass. It takes two hands to make a sound.

Therefore, if the hitter is punished, it is not only because of the punishment of your teacher's behavior, but also because of the maintenance and respect of the teacher's profession and the explanation to the society!

As for teachers, you may really feel wronged, but you should really reflect on why so many teachers who beat students were fine at that time, but you were fine. Is there a problem with your old method and your present method? You should think about it!

It is true that it is a civilized society now, but I think my child has problems and the teacher can punish him appropriately. Spanking them is not a problem. Without rules, you can't make Fiona Fang, and you can't let the teacher tie your hands and feet, otherwise it may be everyone's loss!

What I want to say is that my son is in grade one now, and he was very naughty in primary school. As long as his primary school teachers don't know him. I'm often beaten, too, but let me know when you come back. I asked whose fault it was first. If the teacher made an unintentional mistake, I asked him to write a review and give it to the teacher. Sometimes the teacher thinks he did something wrong, but I didn't apologize. I told him next to me that the teacher would apologize to you, but not now. A few days before graduation, their teacher held a class meeting and apologized. The child came back happily and said that the teacher had apologized to us. In the last class, a class cried bitterly. Although I went to junior high school, I told him that I had time to visit your primary school teacher. The child doesn't refute what I said.

When I was a child, the teacher hit people hard, but we graduated from primary school for more than 20 years, and I never thought about hitting them when I saw the teacher. I just think parents will fight if they are naughty at home. Teachers should not regard it as an end, but as a way of corporal punishment. Is there something wrong with this man? No matter what the original reason is, it has been 20 years, and you are an adult. You also know that hitting people is illegal. It is definitely illegal to hit teachers on purpose, and you should be punished, otherwise the world will be in a mess.

From the teacher's point of view, it is normal to hit students at first. Our primary school teacher beat the students so badly that even his nephew made mistakes. The twin grandson of the brigade secretary angered our class teacher. He came to take over and packed it in a few days!

When he comes, he says, either you change, or you leave, or I leave. It was a real fight, and I was so honest!

Our teacher has a high prestige, and everyone is grateful to him. Without his strict discipline, our class would be finished, and the victims were those of us who studied hard, because there was no teacher at that time!

Thus, truth is truth, and law is law. If you want to fight, you must fight. Sometimes, son, fighting is sure to be immediate, as long as you are fair and just.

I don't know why people who beat teachers are beaten at first, but good students are rarely beaten, so there is a reason for being beaten. On the contrary, it should be avoidable. If the hitter is narrow-minded and resentful, after 20 years, the teacher can appropriately explain to the teacher that he was young and energetic, and this matter will pass. It takes two hands to make a sound.

Therefore, if the hitter is punished, it is not only because of the punishment of your teacher's behavior, but also because of the maintenance and respect of the teacher's profession and the explanation to the society!

As for teachers, you may really feel wronged, but you should really reflect on why so many teachers who beat students were fine at that time, but you were fine. Is there a problem with your old method and your present method? You should think about it!

It is true that it is a civilized society now, but I think my child has problems and the teacher can punish him appropriately. Spanking them is not a problem. Without rules, you can't make Fiona Fang, and you can't let the teacher tie your hands and feet, otherwise it may be everyone's loss!

A few days ago, I wrote an answer about this matter, which was scolded by netizens, saying that I was not worthy to be a teacher, and I was slapped by students every day. Even so, I still stick to my point of view.

In the previous answer, my basic proposition is often hateful. Whether to sentence or not should be decided by the law, based on facts and taking the law as the criterion. This is the basic principle of the rule of law. We can't give a heavy sentence just because this matter has been hyped up by the media.

In this court session, the public prosecution agency prosecuted Chang for the crime of "stirring up trouble", so I specially consulted the legal explanation of "stirring up trouble". My understanding is that "making trouble" is mainly aimed at personal damage to the public environment. Although there are also terms of beating and insulting others at will, beating teachers often has a strong purpose and cannot be said to be arbitrary.

According to my unprofessional understanding, this matter should be investigated for legal responsibility, and it may be more appropriate to use "intentional injury". However, as a professional legal department, the public prosecution agency cannot be unaware of it.

In this regard, I guess that "intentional injury" needs to identify the degree of injury. Although Chang's behavior is very bad, the teacher who was beaten may not even be slightly injured in terms of physical injury. Some people retort that there are also mental injuries. The problem is that mental injury is not easy to measure and identify. Therefore, it is considered to sue the public prosecution agency for the crime of "stirring up trouble".

That's what I'm worried about. There are many incidents of beating people in society, and some even beat people for no reason. Isn't it often reported that old people beat people and insult others on the bus and don't give up their seats? Have these people been charged? We can also imagine that Chang is not so angry when he hits the teacher. The local public security organ will take Chang into custody and the public prosecution organ will prosecute him?

I think most of the people who scold me in the comment area are our teachers. In fact, when the incident happened, I was equally indignant. Until now, I still think that I often pay for it.

It's just that I don't want to see laws and rules dominated by public opinion. And our teacher, this is the victim of the rules being influenced by public opinion.

At present, there are many incidents of speculating on teachers' bad behavior on the Internet. Once the incident is hyped, the relevant departments will quickly take punishment in order to calm public opinion, regardless of rules and procedures. For example, the teacher who punished the students in the early stage was fired three days after the incident. The teacher is wrong, but is it really enough to be expelled?

So I don't defend Chang, I defend Chang, but I want to see the justice of the law.

A long two-year sentence is indispensable.

If I were a teacher, I wouldn't settle down. For twenty years, the teacher beat you, mostly because of education. That's the background of the times. There are few people who haven't been beaten by teachers. Of course, if you are a good student with excellent grades, you may not have a chance to be beaten. I was beaten by the teacher, too. I slapped my deskmate. It's in front of classroom 56. Do I hold grudges? I remember, at that time, I thought I would let the social boy beat the teacher, break the teacher's leg, miss Korosensei and plot with my deskmate for a few days. Of course, it was not implemented, because the new beating thing came again. . .

A classmate was kicked from the third floor to the first floor from the stairs. Strangely, he used to hit so hard that he could hardly see the students go to the doctor or see any scars. Think about students now, it is easy to jump off a building. I just watched a news that a 17-year-old child quarreled with his mother in the car, opened the car door and jumped off the viaduct to die. What's the matter?

Hate a teacher can be remembered for more than 20 years. It's really shocking to see an elderly teacher stop on the road to get revenge.

Over time, I have no resentment against the teacher at all. The teacher is wrong. The mistake is that he is too strict, and it is this rude resort to violence. Isn't this the fault of thousands of years of education in China?

There's a reason for hitting the teacher often, and there's a reason for always emphasizing something? You didn't make a mistake first, when the teacher hit you for no reason? Besides, revenge after 20 years is absolutely forbidden by law. Shooting video communication has pushed itself to the abyss.

According to common sense, teachers are often stopped from hitting people. If someone called the police at that time, they were often arrested and detained for up to ten days.

The teacher didn't call the police and didn't make any noise. He just doesn't want it to spread, so it's hard to be a man. After decades of teaching career, the students who have been taught retaliated and were beaten in the street. Awkward. This is to tell others that being a teacher is a failure.

Often he committed suicide and sent a video to others. One will be passed on, and it will have a chain effect. Finally, a national event will have a very bad influence. Why did the headmaster of the beaten teacher school file a lawsuit? This is fear! How many people worked as teachers and never beat students in that era? If everyone follows suit, how many teachers will survive? Society is in chaos.

Teacher Zhang was slapped several times in the street for no reason. Through the roar of the other party, he learned that the classmate he had beaten had retaliated. Teacher Zhang knows very well that first, heroes don't suffer immediate losses, second, their reputation is affected, and third, they must have hit students at the beginning, so they quickly say sorry! Things should be over here, and teacher Zhang is definitely not hurt too much physically. Often he is angry, and teacher Zhang pays for his rudeness.

However, he often didn't leave it at that, and bluffed to ask a friend to help him take a video of his teacher and send it out, as if to report to the people all over the country that the wicked will get what they deserve. As a result, the situation expanded, causing strong voices in the education sector. Where is the safety of teachers in the country? Teacher Zhang doesn't agree either. Anyway, the old face has lost its dignity. Let's go to the official judge. In fact, even if Mr. Zhang wants to narrow down the scope, I'm afraid the education sector can't promise him. Both parties must obey the court's decision. Although a couple often seek reconciliation by many methods, all their efforts are in vain.

It is difficult to produce effective evidence for teachers to punish students twenty years ago, but often a teacher is proved to be conclusive and will be punished by law, which will eventually end in both sides, playing a warning role, and students who retaliate against teachers will be severely punished by law.

The same thing of educating people, placed in different times and different environments, has very different educational requirements, especially in the past, the educational quality and methods of rural teachers were different, and the old traditional thinking of sticking sticks to show filial piety and not using tools became a common phenomenon. There are some things in life that need to be let go, keep pace with the times, let bygones be bygones, and don't retaliate for violating the law and discipline; At the same time, it also reminds today's education circles to be kind to students, educate people with proper methods and strengthen supervision.