Traditional Culture Encyclopedia - Traditional stories - Do you think the New Water Margin is better than the old one? Why?

Do you think the New Water Margin is better than the old one? Why?

I think the new Water Margin is better.

I have watched the new Water Margin several times, except for some details. For example, in Lu's new play, he is stupid from head to toe and lacks wisdom. Another example is Lin Chong, who looked miserable from the beginning and really entered the show a little early. Being ridiculed as "closing the moon and feeling ashamed of flowers" makes me feel embarrassed.

? I don't think this water margin would be so strong without Song Jiang. Finally, if Song Jiang was bent on wooing, Liangshan heroes would not end up like this. Presumably, if Classical becomes immortal, water margin and Fang La form an alliance, the result will be another scene. I feel that the new Water Margin is well shot, and this version of Song Jiang is also well played. Some places are not handled well, and I think it is also a flaw.

Water margin is a paradise, but the best in the world, and even Lu may not be able to take advantage of it. Playing Ximen Qing turned out to be a narrow victory, which shows Ximen Qing's kung fu. Therefore, Liangshan heroes can beat Ximen Qing no more than 10. It's a pity that I have watched Water Margin so many times. .....

Pan Jinlian died so beautifully, what else is there to say! The director complied with the requirements of the times. Since Lin Chong went to Liangshan, destroyed the boss and retired, he never got a word in front of all the leaders. The real citizens were driven to Liangshan by Wu Yong's despicable means, and the bandits who robbed others went to Liangshan and became heroes who helped heaven. Regarding the debate about the new version of Water Margin, I want to say that everyone has their own ideas and research on Water Margin. Everyone has the right to express himself. Just don't abuse it. If you want to abuse yourself, you'd better have skills. As for why I think it's not bad, I think:

1. Some actors are really good, such as Lu.

2. The background music is very nice.

what do you think? Please leave a comment.