Do you think it's reasonable to charge a certain amount of compensation for finding something and returning it to its owner?

I think if the reward is given by the owner of the lost property, the person who returns the property to the owner can accept it openly. If the owner doesn't want to pay, then the person who finds the thing is better off not asking for it.

You're going to say that I'm just wondering if that's reasonable? Then it's not reasonable!

Because if it's reasonable, the owner will naturally give it, and everyone will be happy! Since the owner is not happy to give the money but also feels uncomfortable, it means that there is something unreasonable here.

The original statement of Mr. Luo Xiang is: Do you think it is morally reasonable for me to ask for 3,000 dollars for an ID card I found? Can social life tolerate it? It can. So of course this is not a crime.

So Mr. Luo Xiang is not saying here that if you pick up someone else's ID card, it is reasonable to ask them for 3,000 dollars. Rather, he is saying that social life can tolerate it, but it does not constitute a crime.

So can you make a request that you unilaterally feel is unreasonable?

Actually, it can be made, because the person making the demand does not find his demand unreasonable, it is the party being asked who finds it unreasonable. If the person who is being asked cannot accept it, he can refuse or negotiate, but if he doesn't bring it up, how can he know if it's reasonable or not?

Mr. Luo Xiang also said in the same video: as for whether you give or not, that's your business, so for this kind of behavior the law has no need to interfere? There isn't! A matter of negotiation between private individuals. Judicial practice there are a large number of such cases, but we are often messy judgment. Often as long as the rights exceed the legal limit will be directly determined why? Extortion and blackmail!

He cited the case of Guo Li, I also think that Guo Li put forward the requirements although the defense feel unreasonable, but for Guo Li is reasonable.

So is it okay for us to ask for payment if we find something? Unreasonable demands are still necessary, in case they are realized?

All I can say is that it would have been 100% wonderful for you to find something and return it to its owner. That's when your brain would have started secreting dopamine and you would have been in a happy mood full of accomplishment. I don't see why you should ask for payment, if you get rejected or disagree, aren't you personally making a good thing into a bad thing for yourself?