Which is better, Xiao or Di?

The modes of flutes are generally D, E, F, G and A, while flutes are generally C, D, E, F and G. Because flutes have no diaphragm, their timbre is low, and flutes vibrate by diaphragm, so their timbre is crisp and high. Generally speaking, there is no need to play Xiao in northern tunes. In my impression, Xiao plays Jiangnan silk and bamboo, which is comparable to C and D tunes. Generally speaking, the music played by Xiao does not pay attention to the complexity of fingering, but pays attention to breath and artistic conception, which is mostly used to play solemn and stirring music. The most commonly used flutes are G and F, and the positions of flute holes of these two sounds are more suitable for people's finger distance. The flute is so short that most people can play it. The easiest keys to learn are e and f. As for fingering, the two are the same, that is, the top hole of the flute is on the back!

Xiao's timbre is deeper and sadder than that of bamboo flute, while bamboo flute changes greatly and has strong expressive force. In fact, the main difference is that the bamboo flute needs to be attached with a flute membrane, while the flute doesn't need to be attached with anything (so the tone of the flute is somewhat similar to some foreign characteristic wind instruments).

Because of the different timbres, none of them are good. The key is what the artistic conception of this song is to express.

In fact, different musical instruments play the same melody, which brings us different feelings-I think this is mainly the difference in timbre!

Therefore, there is no question of who listens well and who doesn't.